Instructions for Reviewers
World Nutrition is a peer‑reviewed journal of the World Public Health Nutrition Association (WPHNA). Peer reviewers play a central role in maintaining the scientific quality, ethical integrity, and relevance of the journal. These instructions provide comprehensive guidance for reviewers invited to assess manuscripts submitted to World Nutrition.
- Role of the Reviewer
Reviewers are expected to provide independent, objective, and constructive assessments of manuscripts within their areas of expertise. Reviews should help editors reach fair decisions and assist authors in improving the quality, clarity, and rigor of their work.
Reviewers act as advisors to the editors and do not make final publication decisions.
- Type of Peer Review
World Nutrition operates a double‑blind peer review system:
- Reviewers do not know the identities of authors
- Authors do not know the identities of reviewers
Reviewers should avoid any actions that might compromise anonymity.
- Confidentiality
All manuscripts received for review are strictly confidential.
Reviewers must:
- Not share manuscripts or related materials with others
- Not discuss the manuscript outside the review process
- Not use any unpublished information for personal or professional advantage
- Not upload manuscripts or content into generative AI tools or external platforms
If expert advice is needed from others, reviewers must first obtain permission from the editor.
- Conflicts of Interest
Reviewers must declare any potential conflicts of interest before accepting a review, including:
- Personal or professional relationships with the presumed authors
- Financial or institutional interests related to the manuscript
- Direct competition or intellectual rivalry
If a conflict exists, reviewers should normally decline the invitation or consult with the editor if uncertain.
- Accepting or Declining a Review Invitation
When invited to review, reviewers should consider:
- Relevance of the manuscript to their expertise
- Ability to provide a review within the requested timeframe
- Absence of conflicts of interest
If declining, reviewers are encouraged to suggest alternative qualified reviewers, where possible. Declines should be done within the journal platform, not by writing to the editor.
- Review Timeline
- Reviewers are typically asked to complete reviews within 2–4 weeks
- Extensions may be requested from the handling editor if needed
- Timely reviews are essential to maintaining an efficient editorial process
- Scope of Review
Reviewers should evaluate manuscripts based on the journal’s aims and scope, which emphasize:
- Public health and community nutrition
- Equity, justice, sustainability, and human rights
- Policy relevance and real‑world implications
- Evaluation Criteria
Reviewers are asked to comment on the following aspects, as applicable:
- Originality and Contribution
- Novelty of the research question or perspective
- Contribution to existing knowledge or practice
- Relevance to public health nutrition
- Scientific and Methodological Quality
- Appropriateness of study design and methods
- Adequacy of sampling technique and size
- Transparency and reproducibility
- Appropriate use of reporting standards (e.g. CONSORT, PRISMA, STROBE)
- Ethical Considerations
- Data and Transparency
- Clarity and completeness of data reporting
- Consistency between results and conclusions
- Presentation and Clarity
- Logical structure and coherence
- Clarity of language and arguments
- Appropriate use of tables and figures
- Interpretation and Implications
- Whether conclusions are supported by data
- Consideration of limitations
- Relevance for policy, practice, or future research
- Reviewer Comments
Reviewers should provide:
Comments to Authors
- Constructive, respectful, and specific feedback
- Suggestions for improvement rather than only criticism
- Clear identification of major and minor issues
Confidential Comments to Editors
- Overall assessment of the manuscript
If reviewers suspect:
- Plagiarism
- Data fabrication or falsification
- Duplicate publication
- Undisclosed AI use
- Ethical violations involving human participants
They should report concerns confidentially to the editor, providing as much detail as possible.
- Editorial Recommendation
Reviewers may recommend one of the following:
- Accept
- Minor revision
- Major revision
- Reject
Final decisions are made by the editors, taking all reviews into account.
Recognition of Reviewers
World Nutrition values the voluntary contribution of reviewers. While reviews are anonymous, the journal may:
- Provide confirmation letters upon request
- Publicly acknowledge reviewers annually (without linking names to specific manuscripts)
- Exceptional reviewers may also be considered for inclusion on the Editorial Board, with a professional bio profile displayed on the journal website.
Reviewer Conduct
Reviewers are expected to:
- Be objective and unbiased
- Avoid discriminatory or derogatory language
- Respect diversity of perspectives and contexts
- Support equity, inclusion, and global representation in science
Contact and Support
For questions regarding a review assignment, reviewers may contact the editorial office:
Email: editorinchief@worldnutritionjournal.org
By agreeing to review for World Nutrition, reviewers confirm that they have read, understood, and agreed to abide by these instructions.











