Peer Review Policy
Peer Review and Production Policies and Procedures
Overview
World Nutrition is committed to upholding the highest standards of scholarly quality, ethical publishing, and editorial integrity. All manuscripts submitted to the journal undergo rigorous, independent, and unbiased peer review, in line with international best practice and the principles of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).
Type of Peer Review
World Nutrition operates a double-blind peer-review system for all research articles, literature reviews, and scholarly commentaries that involve empirical evidence.
- Authors do not know the identity of reviewers
- Reviewers do not know the identity of the authors
This process is designed to ensure fairness, minimize bias, and promote objective assessment based solely on scholarly merit, originality, and methodological rigor.
Peer Review Workflow and Timelines
The peer review process follows a structured, transparent editorial workflow designed to ensure rigor while maintaining reasonable timelines.
- Submission and Initial Editorial Screening (1 week plus time for author revision if required)
Upon submission, manuscripts undergo preliminary evaluation by the Editorial Office and handling editors to assess:
- Alignment with journal aims and scope
- Compliance with author guidelines
- Methodological soundness
- Ethical approval and reporting standards
- Plagiarism screening
- Screening to ensure that use of AI conforms with the authors’ AI use declaration
Manuscripts may be declined at this stage without external review.
- Assignment to Reviewers (1 week)
Eligible manuscripts are assigned to a minimum of two independent external reviewers selected based on subject expertise, publication record, and absence of conflicts of interest.
- External Peer Review (3–6 weeks)
Reviewers are requested to provide structured and constructive assessments addressing:
- Scientific quality and originality
- Methodological rigor
- Clarity of presentation
- Ethical considerations
- Relevance to public health nutrition research, policy, and practice
- Author Revision (if possible, ≤6 weeks)
Authors are usually invited to revise manuscripts in response to reviewer comments except in cases where the editor-in-chief judges that revisions will not be able to solve serious problems, in which case the manuscript is declined. Revised manuscripts may undergo additional rounds of peer review when necessary.
- Editorial Processes (3 weeks plus time required for author revisions)
An Assistant Editor reviews the revised version, determines whether it represents a satisfactory response to the reviewers' input, and, if needed, requests additional changes from the authors. The Editor-in-Chief or designated Handling Editor then edits the manuscript. This often results in at least one further round of requests to the authors for further changes. The Editor-in-Chief then makes the final decision on publication. Decisions are based on reviewer reports, scholarly merit, originality, relevance, and ethical compliance.
- Typesetting
Once accepted, manuscripts are typeset utilizing a process involving interaction with the authors. This may require a few weeks, depending on how long it takes authors to respond to typesetter requests.
Editorial Decision Categories
Manuscripts are assigned one of the following decisions:
- Accept
- Minor Revisions Required
- Major Revisions Required
- Decline – Resubmission Encouraged
- Reject
All decisions are accompanied by anonymized reviewer reports and editorial guidance or explanations.
The typical time from submission to acceptance is approximately 10–12 weeks plus time required by authors to make revisions, depending largely on reviewer availability and responsiveness.

Reviewer Selection and Responsibilities
Reviewers are selected based on:
- Subject-matter expertise
- Academic or professional experience
- Relevant publication record
- Absence of conflicts of interest
- Commitment to ethical, constructive, and timely peer review
The journal actively promotes diversity among reviewers, considering geography, gender, discipline, and institutional affiliation.
Reviewers are required to:
- Treat manuscripts as confidential
- Declare conflicts of interest
- Provide objective, constructive, and evidence-based assessments
- Refrain from using artificial intelligence tools to generate peer-review reports
Conflict of Interest Management
All reviewers and editors must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest before participating in editorial evaluation. Individuals with conflicts are recused from the review or decision-making process. The journal adheres to COPE guidelines for managing conflict-of-interest disclosures and ethical concerns.
Research Integrity and Ethical Oversight
World Nutrition adheres strictly to COPE principles in managing ethical issues, allegations of misconduct, data falsification, plagiarism, duplicate publication, and authorship disputes. Ethical investigations are conducted transparently, fairly, and confidentially, with appropriate corrective actions taken when necessary.
Appeals Process
Authors who believe an editorial decision was made in error may submit a formal written appeal within 14 days of receiving the decision.
Appeals should include a detailed rebuttal addressing reviewer and editorial comments and must be submitted to: editor@worldnutritionjournal.org
Appeals are reviewed independently by the Editor-in-Chief in consultation with senior editorial leadership or external experts where appropriate. Decisions following an appeal are final.
Transparency and Accountability
World Nutrition maintains full transparency in its editorial decision-making, peer-review procedures, and publication ethics. All editorial policies are publicly available, regularly reviewed, and updated in alignment with evolving best practices in scholarly publishing.











